Coalition plan to bar non-citizens from NDIS prompts debate
The Coalition wants to stop non-citizens joining the NDIS from July 2028, but a Motley Fool investment chief says the scheme's structure is the real problem.
The Coalition says it will target non-citizens on the National Disability Insurance Scheme as one way to rein in the scheme's ballooning costs, a proposal discussed on 4BC Brisbane.
Under the opposition's plan, access to the scheme for non-citizens would end from July 1, 2028. People already receiving NDIS support would be grandfathered, meaning they would keep it. Current exemptions under international agreements would continue to apply.
The Coalition has asked the Parliamentary Budget Office to examine NDIS payments to non-citizens. According to the source, spending on that group is expected to rise above $5 billion a year in the 2030s.
The 4BC host noted that long-term residents who have paid taxes and hold permanent residency can normally access benefits, so any change would need to be handled carefully. The host also suggested there had been some rorting of the scheme.
Scott Phillips, chief investment officer at The Motley Fool, said the scheme has cost many multiples of what was forecast when it was established with bipartisan support under the Gillard government. He said it is now almost, if not already, more expensive than the aged pension.
Phillips argued that restricting access by citizenship would not necessarily cut costs, because permanent residents could simply apply for citizenship and the underlying cost would remain. He said he expected a rush into the citizenship queue.
He described the scheme's structure as the central problem. In his view, a three-sided market, with a payer, a service provider and a recipient who are all different parties, gives none of them a strong incentive to keep spending in check. He said this encourages overcharging and over-servicing.
Phillips said cuts proposed by either side amounted to band-aids on a broken structure. He called for the scheme to be rebuilt while still protecting people who need support.
The host said that, in principle, he had liked the idea of trusting people with money to buy the services that work for them, but pointed to frustrations people face when dealing with providers.
Video: 4BC Brisbane.
Key questions
- What is the Coalition proposing for the NDIS?
- The Coalition plans to stop non-citizens accessing the NDIS from July 1, 2028, with existing recipients grandfathered.
- How much could NDIS spending on non-citizens reach?
- According to the source, it is expected to rise above $5 billion a year in the 2030s. The Coalition has asked the Parliamentary Budget Office to examine the figures.
- Why does Scott Phillips doubt the plan would cut costs?
- He says permanent residents could take up citizenship, so the cost would not change. He argues the scheme's structure is the underlying problem.